5. Fish Tacos Make-your-own tacos are a fun dish to offer at a Super Bowl party because they are filling and interactive, plus people can pick and choose their toppings. And no, you do not need to offer fried fish; baked or grilled fish tacos are equally delicious and quick to make. This recipe calls for Mahi Mahi or Orata, but use whatever flaky white fish looks fresh. And if you don’t have a BBQ or grill pan ready to go, you can bake the fish as well.