So which is the best self tanner? According to Consumer Reports, Jergens Natural Glow Daily Moisturizer is the one product that landed on several “Best of” roundups and received high marks from both users and independent expert reviewers. Satisfied consumers thought this drugstore choice gave them “a very natural-looking tint that appears gradually and subtly.” This is for the user who doesn’t want a sudden change in their appearance and an ongoing tint of color to make them look healthier.