First, take a deep breath. No, your car will not spontaneously combust. You are not creating some volatile chemistry experiment in your wheel well.
The short answer is a huge, resounding yes. You can absolutely fill nitrogen tires with regular old air.
In fact, the universe—and your local gas station—are basically begging you to do it. Especially at 2 AM in the freezing cold.
But Won’t It Ruin the Magic?
I hear you. You paid for that nitrogen. Maybe you even sat through a boring sales pitch at the tire shop. "It's better for fuel economy! It doesn't leak as fast!" they promised.
And hey, they weren't totally lying. Nitrogen molecules are a little bigger than oxygen molecules. So they do seep out of your rubber tires just slightly slower.
But here is the cold, hard truth. Air is already 78% nitrogen. You aren't betraying a sacred oath. You are just adding a little bit of party mix to the punch bowl.